I once heard a comedian joke, “I don’t understand the allure of skiing. I mean you put these slippery things on your feet and slide down the mountain. Try putting skis on and NOT sliding down the mountain, now that’s a challenge.”
That’s kind of how I felt while reading John Green’s bestselling Young Adult (YA) novel The Fault Within Our Stars. Try writing a love story between two cancer-stricken teenagers that doesn’t make readers cry, now that’s a challenge. I just finished the novel last night and am strictly in the “it’s okay” camp. John Green is a likable guy with a huge following. I like his Youtube videos, and admit I’d watched a few videos before I realized he was an author. While I didn’t hate the novel, it didn’t wow me either. Okay, a tear may have fallen, but this novel didn’t stir up the emotions of many, many of the books I’ve read over the years.
Like any novel that becomes a huge financial success, the detractors have come out of the woodwork. Slate Magazine ran a piece recently where writer Ruth Graham derisively stated that adults should be embarrassed to be caught reading YA novels. The article can be found here.This article created an immediate backlash on Twitter, with people defending the YA genre. My favorite quote from this debate came from author Jennifer Weiner who, when asked why she would defend YA, tweeted, “First they come for your YA and then they come for your chick lit.” Hilarious and true.
So here’s my take. For me, reading YA is like eating Macaroni and Cheese. I’ve known many kids who grew up on a diet of mac and cheese, it is one of the few things they will eat – and they eat bowls of it. My son was an example of this, but now his palate has matured. As a college junior, he has developed a more adventurous appetite and turned into an opinionated “foodie.” As an adult, I enjoy mac and cheese occasionally. It’s a comfort food.
Our reading choices are similar. Is there a lit pyramid like the food pyramid? I tend to read short stories about suburban angst – and have to break out of my habit to read other stuff – non-fiction, poetry, chick lit, YA, etc. Do you have a favorite genre and have to “flex” your reading habits to try new genres? Anyway, I’ve had my fill of mac and cheese for the year, though maybe next summer I’ll have another serving.